Home » Blog » Pigeon Forge Dining » The Most Popular Menu Items at The Old Mill in Pigeon Forge
most popular menu items at the old mill

The Most Popular Menu Items at The Old Mill in Pigeon Forge

The Old Mill was built in Pigeon Forge in the early 1800s. At one time, it actually produced electricity for the town. Now, it is the hot spot in Pigeon Forge to get some of the best Southern food you’ve ever tasted! It’s grown to be a favorite among both locals and visitors – and for good reason because the food is delicious!

Here are some of the most popular items on the menu at The Old Mill in Pigeon Forge – they might make your mouth water just reading about them!

The Old Mill Restaurant in Pigeon Forge

5 Most Popular Items at The Old Mill in Pigeon Forge

1. Southern Fried Chicken Tenders

Hand-cut, generous strips of chicken, seasoned and breaded with their own special blends of spices and stone-ground breading (made right at The Old Mill), then fried to a crispy perfection.

2. Traditional Turkey and Dressing

Oven-roasted daily in their kitchens, slices of turkey are served with a generous helping of cornbread dressing, covered with turkey gravy and a side of cranberry sauce. The portion is very large – be sure to share or be prepared to take a to-go box!

3. Pork Chop

The hand-cut, boneless pork chops, perfectly seasoned and covered in Old Mill breading. The pork chops are fried just enough so they stay juicy with a crispy crust.

4. Country Fried Steak

Beef cuts are tenderized then dusted to order with the popular Old Mill breading, fried golden brown then covered with their homemade gravy.

5. Southern Style Corn Chowder

Their delicious creamy chowder is definitely a MUST-HAVE when you visit The Old Mill. It comes with every order as an appetizer and we know you’ll love it. The staff at The Old Mill says it tastes like a creamy potato soup (it does!). It combines corn kernels, onions, potatoes and bell peppers and is served with homemade corn fritters which are another must at The Old Mill!

5 Things You Can Only Find at The Old Mill in Pigeon Forge

The Old Mill on the Little Pigeon River, a popular site to visit on Pigeon Forge vacations.

Are you looking for a dish that you can’t find at other restaurants in the Smokies? The Old Mill has a few stars on the menu that you won’t find a better version of anywhere else!

1. Corn Fritters

Kerneled corn dipped and battered in Old Mill breading and fried to golden perfection. These are served with every dinner as an appetizer along with the Corn Chowder. You won’t find anything like them in Pigeon Forge!

2. Spareribs & Sauerkraut

Have you ever heard of spare ribs & sauerkraut? We hadn’t either, but it’s a delicious combination! Their slow roasted pork ribs are baked with sauerkraut, onion and seasonings to make this special country experience.

3. Southern Fried Beef Liver

Crispy, fried cuts of tender beef liver, seasoned with a special spice blend and covered with caramelized onions.

4. Southern Fried Chicken Livers

You definitely aren’t going to find chicken livers all over Pigeon Forge, but we know many of you love them! These crispy-fried chicken livers are seasoned and hand-breaded in a special Old Mill breading and seasoning.

5. Meatloaf

The Old Mill keeps their meatloaf old-fashioned, making it the ultimate comfort food for any vacation. You might be able to get meatloaf all over the south, but you won’t find meatloaf like this because it’s made with a special blend of Old Mill herbs and spices!

Top 5 Desserts to Order at the Old Mill

The best part! You can’t visit The Old Mill and skip out on dessert! Their desserts are made fresh daily from scratch and are truly some of the best you’ll find in the south! Here’s a few of the most popular desserts at The Old Mill:

1. Pecan Pieold mill pecan pie

The absolute favorite is their pecan pie! Pecans picked at the right time, and mixed up in a sweet and special batter to create the perfect traditional Southern classic dessert.

2. Blackberry Cobbler

Their blackberries are picked right off the bush! They add some sugar and cook them down to make the perfect pie filling paired with a homemade crust. It is served with vanilla bean ice cream.

3. Coconut Cream Pie

Their coconut cream pie is whipped to perfection! If you’re looking for something light, but not overly sweet, this is the one to choose!

4. Chocolate Cake

You can’t go wrong with homemade chocolate cake! It has a wonderful chocolate taste without being overly sweet!

5. Key Lime Pie

Their Key Lime Pie dessert has a silky whipped texture with a crumbly crust, and each bite has a fresh, lime taste. It’s a perfect choice for summertime.

The Little Pigeon River at The Old Mill in Pigeon Forge.

Make sure you visit The Old Mill hungry and ready to eat! Portions are always large and are great for sharing! When you visit The Old Mill in Pigeon Forge, you can expect to be treated with authentic and genuine Southern hospitality that makes you feel right at home!

Want some of these recipes to make at home? Click here for our favorite Old Mill recipes, including the recipe for Corn Fritters and Pecan Pie!